Thread: Which is better Harry potter or Twilight ?

Originally Posted by Shana

No second thoughts! Definitely Harry Potter! And I've read most of the Twilight books and watched all in that franchise. But somehow I ended up hating the movies as well as the books. The concept of a girl who loves a boy and then loves a another boy a lot more is a bit creepy fro me. How could a girl have 2 guys hang in there waiting for her and give them both hopes of being their one and true love?
"I love you, but I love him more" The dialogue which made me hate twilight. And Bella's daughter ending up with her ex? Seriously?

HARRY POTTER IS 100 TIMES BETTER THAN TWILIGHT!

I always wanted to listen this doubt from a girl. I also felt creepy for that part. But I thought after watching the movie that I should change my ideology. The girl felt for the other man because of her loneliness. I thought it is not her fault and I began to change my thoughts on it. I haven't read the novels. But what do you think? Did I make a wrong conclusion?

Originally Posted by Karikaalan

I always wanted to listen this doubt from a girl. I also felt creepy for that part. But I thought after watching the movie that I should change my ideology. The girl felt for the other man because of her loneliness. I thought it is not her fault and I began to change my thoughts on it. I haven't read the novels. But what do you think? Did I make a wrong conclusion?

loneliness doesn't make someone fall in love. Love makes someone fall in love, actually. If she fell for Jacob because she was lonely, then she was clearly using her and nothing else.
Because, when Edward came into the equation, she was totally into both of them, coz now she has two guys fighting for her love. Not so lonely now, is she?